Insights

What is the Home Country Bias and why this is slowing many Australian investors down in achieving their trading goals

30 January 2018  |  EDUCATION

In the year 2017, the EWA, an ETF (Footnote #1) which tracks the performance of Australia’s share market has grown by 19.9%. Although this is a reasonably sound return on investment, the global average over the year 2017 was 29%, where South Korea’s (EWY) ETF saw a return of 49.2%, Hong Kong (EWH) a return of 36.5% and China (FXI) 36.2%. Australian investors are known to have a “home country bias” when it comes to picking stocks, where on average, an Australian equities portfolio is made up of 66% (Footnote #2). Australian shares. As such, by allocating a high portfolio weight into domestic stocks, Australian investors may be missing out on potential gains presented by international markets, as well as the benefits of having a more diversified portfolio.

  1. An exchange traded fund, or ETF is a marketable security that owns its underlying assets (stocks, bonds, currency, etc.) and divides ownership of those assets into shares. Unlike mutual funds, an ETF trades like a common stock on a stock exchange, and experiences price changes as they are bought and sold.
  2. Vanguard research

Figure 1: Country ETFs: 2017 Total Returns (in US $)

Country Ticker 2017 YTD Country Ticker 2017 YTD Country Ticker 2017 YTD
Poland PLND 54.8% Thailand THD 31.5% Switzerland EWL 23.4%
Argentina ARGT 53.9% Taiwan EWT 30.4% Norway NORW 22.4%
Austria EWO 52.5% Nigeria NGE 29.9% US SPY 22.3%
South Korea EWY 49.2% Ireland EIRL 29.8% Sweden EWD 21.9%
Chile ECH 41.8% Peru EPU 29.7% United Kingdom EWU 21.6%
Vietnam VNM 38.8% France EWQ 29.1% Philippines EPHE 20.2%
India PIN 38.5% Italy EWI 28.7% Australia EWA 19.9%
Turkey TUR 37.6% Germany EWG 27.4% Indonesia EIDO 19.4%
Hong Kong EWH 36.5% Spain EWP 27.0% Canada EWC 15.7%
China FXI 36.2%
Egpyt EGPT 25.8% Mexico EWW 14.5%
South Africa EZA 36.0% Malaysia EWM 24.3% Israel EIS 12.8%
Singapore EWS 34.8%
Japan EWJ 24.3% Colombia GXG 11.9%
Greece GREK 34.8% New Zealand ENZL 24.1% Saudi Arabia KSA 6.2%
Netherlands EWN 33.8% Belgium EWK 23.7% UAE UAE 5.0%
Portugal PGAL 31.6% Brazil EWZ 23.7% Russsia ERUS 3.9%

Source: Charlie Biello, Pension Partners

Home Country Bias

Home country bias in this context refers to the tendency for investors to hold a significant portion of their portfolio in domestic equities. Australian investors have shown a stronger home country bias than many other developed countries, where 66% of Australian shareholders hold only domestic shares.

Figure 2: Equity Market Home Country Bias

Source: Based on Vanguard Research 2016

Why do Australian investors prefer to invest domestically?

There are a number of factors that contribute to Australia’s home country bias. Common reasons such as familiarity, currency concerns, better return expectations and lower investment costs are consistent across other markets. However, the main factors which cause home country equity bias in Australia are the higher costs of entry (brokerage costs) to international stocks compared to accessing the Australian share market. Other reasons are due to its tax system and the performance benefits associated with the dividend imputation system – Australian investors place a higher value on companies which pay dividends with imputation (franking) credits attached to them. These credits are particularly attractive to superannuation investors, as it helps them increase the value of their dividend due to the lower tax rate on superannuation investments. With that being said, although Australia provides desirable tax concessions, the Australian equities market accounts for approximately 2.4% of the global equity market . Therefore, investors who are only investing domestically are not only limiting the benefits associated with diversification, but are also missing out on many opportunities in the global equity markets.

Why should I invest internationally?

The main benefit of investing internationally is portfolio diversification. Diversification is a risk management technique which seeks to smooth out unsystematic risk events in a portfolio, so the positive performance of some investments neutralizes the negative performance of others. Ultimately, the aim of diversification is to ensure certain shocks to a specific section of your portfolio does not affect the other sections, where your gains/losses are uncorrelated with each other. For example, by only investing into Australian stocks, an investor’s portfolio may be at high risk of losing capital if there is a significant event that happens domestically, causing the stock market to crash. On the other hand, if the portfolio was diversified across various stock markets, only the domestic stocks would be affected, rather than the entire portfolio.

Furthermore, as Figure 1 demonstrates, Australia’s share market performance in the year 2017, measured by ETF performance shows Australia is lacking when compared with the rest of the world. This may be because the Australian share market is heavily influenced by performance the mining and financial sectors – both of which have not performed great as of this year. On the other hand, for example, The United States has seen strong growth in its technology sector, and China has continued to grow its manufacturing sector at a sound pace. The Australian market, on the other hand does not present as many opportunities into these sectors, and finding opportunities to diversify only in Australia may be difficult given the economic landscape.

By investing only in Australia, you are missing out on potentially higher gains that other markets present, as well as limiting beneficial effects of diversification. A common theme behind why Australian’s don’t invest internationally is due to the lack of access, and high costs associated with it. Currently, purchasing or selling shares in the US market will on average cost you between $19.95 - $59.95 USD. At Monex, we strive to provide a platform which gives you access easy to multiple markets, all at a very fair and competitive price. Monex is unique as it provides access to over 50,000 listed securities across 12 global stock markets, all controlled by a multi wallet currency with brokerage ranging between 0.10-0.30% (starting at 9.99USD). To find out more information regarding available markets and brokerage costs, please visit Fees and Charges page.

Risk Disclaimer: The information above is of general nature only and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or investment needs. Prior to you make an investment decision, please make sure you carefully read and fully understand our Financial Services Guide, Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy and other relevant documents that you can obtain from this website. Monex Securities Australia Pty Ltd (AFSL No. 363972; ABN 84 142 210 179) is the Financial services provider. Financial products trading carries risks and may not be suitable for all investors. You are strongly recommended to seek independent financial advice before making any investment decisions.

,

Related Articles

There is no doubt about the strong economic links between Australia and Asia. According to the Australian Trade and Investment Commission, the Asian region accounted for 62%..

Exchange-traded funds or ETFs are a type of fund that owns the underlying assets (stocks, commodities, bonds, etc.) and divides ownership of those assets into shares. ETFs are bought and sold l..

Low Brokerage Offer